A Colombian online store processes hundreds of orders a month using a popular local payment gateway. One day chargebacks start rolling in — customers claiming to their bank they never authorized the purchase — and the store discovers an attacker had been using stolen cards to make purchases for weeks, targeting their store specifically because its anti-fraud controls were weaker than the competition's. The store doesn't just lose the shipped merchandise; it also faces chargeback fees and, if the pattern repeats enough, the risk of the payment gateway suspending its service for being flagged as high-risk.
How Attackers Operate Against Payment Gateways
Stolen card testing (carding). Attackers use lists of card numbers obtained from previous data breaches and make small, fast purchases across multiple merchants to identify which cards are still active, before using them for higher-value purchases.
Exploiting merchants with weak validation. Stores that don't properly verify the billing address (AVS) or the card's security code (CVV) become preferred targets, precisely because they offer less friction for fraud.
Brute-force attacks on payment forms, trying card data combinations at high speed until finding one that works, when the merchant has no attempt limits or CAPTCHA on the checkout process.
Impersonating the payment interface itself, through malicious code injected into the site (an attack type known as "e-skimming") that captures card data directly during the legitimate payment process, without the buyer or merchant noticing immediately.
The Real Cost Beyond the Individual Chargeback
Every chargeback carries an associated fee, regardless of whether the merchant wins or loses the dispute. But the more serious damage is usually reputational within the payments ecosystem itself: gateways monitor each merchant's chargeback rate, and exceeding certain thresholds can result in higher fees, fund holds, or in severe cases, service termination — which can leave an online store with no way to process payments while it finds a new provider.
Technical Controls That Actually Reduce Fraud
Address verification (AVS) and security code (CVV) enabled and required on every transaction, with no exceptions for conversion convenience.
Rate limits on payment attempts, blocking or flagging for manual review multiple consecutive failed attempts from the same session or IP address.
3D Secure authentication when the gateway supports it, which shifts part of the verification responsibility to the card-issuing bank and significantly reduces fraud with stolen cards.
Monitoring for unusual patterns, like high-value orders shipping to addresses that don't geographically match the billing address, or multiple orders from the same card in a short window.
Periodic security audits of the checkout process, to catch vulnerabilities like e-skimming before an attacker exploits them — this is exactly the kind of review a cybersecurity audit focused on e-commerce platforms covers.
What to Do If You're Already Seeing Elevated Chargebacks
Review disputed transaction patterns for common signals (same IP address, same card range, same product pattern), temporarily tighten controls even if they slightly reduce conversion, and consider a full technical review of the payment process to rule out the site itself being compromised.
Frequently asked questions
Is my store liable if a customer uses a stolen card without my knowledge?
It depends on the controls you had active at the time of the transaction. Merchants without basic verification (AVS, CVV) tend to assume more liability in disputes than those with documented robust controls.
Does 3D Secure hurt my store's conversion rate?
It can introduce an extra checkout step, but the reduction in fraud and chargebacks generally offsets any added friction, especially for merchants already dealing with fraud problems.
How do I know if my site has malicious code capturing payment data (e-skimming)?
It requires a specialized technical review of the site's code and integrated third-party scripts. It's not detectable through simple visual inspection of the site working normally.
What happens if my chargeback rate exceeds my gateway's threshold?
It generally results in increased fees, stricter review of every transaction, or in severe cases, service suspension — which is why it's important to act on the first signs of a fraud pattern, not after it escalates.
Let's talk
Payment gateway fraud combines a technical problem with a business problem — both need attention at the same time. At T.I. RESCUE we assess the full security of e-commerce platforms through our cybersecurity audits. Has your online store seen an unusual spike in chargebacks? Let's talk.
Contact usYou may also like
Comments (0)
Be the first to comment.